Nah, Federation is extremely paranoid about genetic manipulations and it didn't went well with Vulcan's IDIC.
The Feds are paranoid about genetic engineering for "improvements" or major changes, but it appears they're ok with genetic tinkering to correct genetic diseases. Not sure how the Vulcans fit into this; they trot out IDIC, but they sure don't engineer *themselves* to be very different. Hell, they mostly all have the same *haircut.*
 
I hail from a land of non-English as well. Perhaps people like me should strive to become fully conversant in today's lingua franca in this forum...
You are right to point out that the language used is a "Lingua Franca".
Had the Net been available in the years up to 1700 we would all have used Church Latin (even Protestants had to).
Between 1700 and 1900 French became the established language between nations.
Germany's role in science, engineering and mathematics meant many international publications were published in German.
Air Travel and US domination of the global entertainment industry plus the global presence of Yanks and Brits from WW2 on have made English the current language of use.
I would add that unlike French and Latin English has been flexible in its grammar and adoption of foreign words and usage.
This is underlined by its use by two large and ancient societies: China and India when dealing with the outside world.
 
Yeah, a good way to dealt with such lunacies as religious beliefs, for example)
Despite what characters like Picard say, religion is clearly still rampagingly popular in the 25th century. The Bajorans and Klingons, for example, are blisteringly religious; and while humans don't seem all that demonstrative about it, there are clearly still a bunch of human religions. If "tribal" faiths such as Chacotay's are still out there, it's a safe bet that there are Catholics and Mormons and Hindus and such.

In reality, there are doubtless *more* religions among humanity. Not only would a bunch of humans adopt alien religions (I'm sure the Vulcan and Klingon religions would have armies of human adherents), humans have Actually Met ACTUAL GODs out there. There is now objective evidence that Apollo & co were real. Q and the like show up weekly. The Organians did their thing. There will be V'Ger worshippers and Whale Probe cultists. The Orange Catholic Church of Borg, Reformed, is doubtless popular.
 
It is interesting to compare Star Trek TOS which reflected the somewhat sniffy attitude to religion I grew up with in the 60s at home and school. It was regarded as "old fashioned" and ignored rather than attacked.
By the 1970s perhaps on the back of Eastern Mysticism (The Beatles were into this amongst many) and a flood of US Christian evangelists this attitude was no longer fashionable.
Picard's galaxy is completely different from Kirk's. One can only speculate on how Harry Mudd would have got on with the Ferengi. Diversity had arrived and that included religious sects.
 
Despite what characters like Picard say, religion is clearly still rampagingly popular in the 25th century. The Bajorans and Klingons, for example, are blisteringly religious; and while humans don't seem all that demonstrative about it, there are clearly still a bunch of human religions. If "tribal" faiths such as Chacotay's are still out there, it's a safe bet that there are Catholics and Mormons and Hindus and such.
So we could safely assume that Federation is not fond of -

few minutes under the Neural Neutralizer can likely clear it up.

About the popularity of religion in 25th century - if you remove a material greed from religion (no reason to get into your believer's pockets, since most goods are free anyway) and the fear of death (it was stated by Rodenberry, that humans of 25th century view death as sad, but natural course of events, and do not actually fear it anymore), then peoples would likely start to practice religion more as a way of spiritual self-discovery and self-improvement. So there is likely a lot of religious peoples in Federation, but relatively few priests.
 
if you remove a material greed from religion (no reason to get into your believer's pockets, since most goods are free anyway)
[Assuming an afterlife] Now you have L. Ron Hubbard spinning in his grave.
 
So we could safely assume that Federation is not fond of -

Meaning unclear.

About the popularity of religion in 25th century - if you remove a material greed from religion (no reason to get into your believer's pockets, since most goods are free anyway) and the fear of death (it was stated by Rodenberry, that humans of 25th century view death as sad, but natural course of events, and do not actually fear it anymore)

Yeah, he also said that people don't have interpersonal issues anymore, humans don't argue, certainly don't fight, blah, blah, blah. That nonsense didn't last. Witness any scene of impending destruction, and you'll see hordes of crew, passengers, civvies, etc. beating feet to the escape pods because they sure as hell DO fear death. Nobody not a moron doesn't fear death. Look at "Siege of AR-558." Them humans had a good healthy fear of death, cuz they've seen it.

, then peoples would likely start to practice religion more as a way of spiritual self-discovery and self-improvement. So there is likely a lot of religious peoples in Federation, but relatively few priests.
Probably a lot of AI priests.
 
Someone should make a "trek setting but the people are actually people"
Lower Decks are a very rare case of loving desconstruction; they make fun of cliches and weak parts of original, while respecting its spirit.

"Drop this alien AI, it's heavy!"
"No! It also have right to exist!"
"But he is evil!"
"Yes. But we are Starfleet!"

P.S. The evil AI in question actually changed its ways for good... eventually)
 
Yeah, he also said that people don't have interpersonal issues anymore, humans don't argue, certainly don't fight, blah, blah, blah. That nonsense didn't last. Witness any scene of impending destruction, and you'll see hordes of crew, passengers, civvies, etc. beating feet to the escape pods because they sure as hell DO fear death. Nobody not a moron doesn't fear death. Look at "Siege of AR-558." Them humans had a good healthy fear of death, cuz they've seen it.
Not being willing to die and fearing death is a different things. I admit, that the borderline is relatively thin, but essentially it could be drawn at rationality. If someone is willing to do anything to get even a totally false hope of avoiding death (like giving his money to strangerly dressed men, who sprout nonsence about talking snakes, winged wheels with eyes, ect.) - then he is fearing death to irrational, instinctive degree.
 
With most women's waists, a pistol on the belt is difficult to draw. A shoulder holster is better for curvy women.

Also, a pistol across the spine is a terrible idea. You land flat on your back and you'll never walk again.
The idea is even more dangerous for mounted units. In 1937 the mule that my father was riding was upset when he was wounded and threw its rider who fell backwards on his rifle. By incredible luck, Artillery Sergeant Manuel Miranda fell into a deep stream and lived to procreate.:)
 

Attachments

  • images.jpg
    images.jpg
    8.5 KB · Views: 9
  • kaw-2.jpg
    kaw-2.jpg
    36.1 KB · Views: 7
Not being willing to die and fearing death is a different things. I admit, that the borderline is relatively thin, but essentially it could be drawn at rationality.

Other than showing Klingons being overly jazzed about the chance to die entertainingly, Star Trek's depictions of people facing death are not terribly different than *non* Star Trek depictions of people facing death.

Actual humans today:
1) generally know that death is a natural, inevitable part of life
2) generally believe in an afterlife
3) Generally seem to believe that they themselves are bound towards a "better world" in that afterlife

And yet, knowing that, people today are scared to death of death. What would people in Star Trek world have discovered that would make them suddenly, after a hundred thousand years of humanity having a healthy fear of death, suddenly not fear it anymore? The black mountain? The koala?
 
What would people in Star Trek world have discovered that would make them suddenly, after a hundred thousand years of humanity having a healthy fear of death, suddenly not fear it anymore?
Proof of access to an afterlife that looks desirable.
Mark Twain wrote a story where hell (entertaining) was a better place than heaven (boring), so YMMV.
Personal heaven or hell? Ideologically or religiously segregated afterlife? An opt-out when immortality proves to be unbearable?
 
2) generally believe in an afterlife
3) Generally seem to believe that they themselves are bound towards a "better world" in that afterlife
The second and third is essentially our attempts to rationalize our own mortality, born out of self-preservation instincst of primates. Since we did not exactly have instincts, but still have self-preservation fears, we attempt to rationalize them into existence of afterlife. And religions discovered that it's a great way of getting into other peoples pockets, by playing on their fear of death. No pockets to steal from (i.e. a post-scarity future) - significanly less interest from religion to play with people's fears. And if religions lost interest in scaring peoples, it would stand to reason that peoples would simply outlive the fear itself.
 
Bread today Jam tomorrow. And whether it's priests or politicians we always fall for it.
 
. No pockets to steal from (i.e. a post-scarity future)
Post scarcity doesnt mean no pockets. Replicators cant make land, for instance. Or provide services. There will always be an economy.

- significanly less interest from religion to play with people's fears. And if religions lost interest in scaring peoples, it would stand to reason that peoples would simply outlive the fear itself.
The universe of Star Trek is DAMN scary,from mundane threats like Klingons and pirates to Borg, Doomsday Machines, Vger, space "gods" of all kinds, other universes invading, time travel warfare, etc. Religions will find fertile ground.
 
The universe of Star Trek is DAMN scary,from mundane threats like Klingons and pirates to Borg, Doomsday Machines, Vger, space "gods" of all kinds, other universes invading, time travel warfare, etc. Religions will find fertile ground.
Now that you list it out like that, Star Trek seems like a very "Roman" setting.

Its not superstition if gods are really out there ready to smite down people that wronged them.

Polytheism roughly is a single belief system and relationships with powerful beings is diplomacy, not "religion." I guess "religion" is practically a insult against belief systems that is based on the unobservable.
What would people in Star Trek world have discovered that would make them suddenly, after a hundred thousand years of humanity having a healthy fear of death, suddenly not fear it anymore?
Transporter accident ;)

But really, mortality in a world of perfect transporter clones is just bizarre. Any non-stupid application of the tech would have people running dozens of clones and backups and so on in an afternoon.
 
Now that you list it out like that, Star Trek seems like a very "Roman" setting.

Its not superstition if gods are really out there ready to smite down people that wronged them.

And in Star Trek, there are a LOT of "gods." Their interactions with each other remain unexplored outside of beta canon.

So far in alpha canon it seem that the only reason why humanity/the Federation haven't been smited by some god or other is some combo of dumb luck and that we're still too small to be noticed.

But really, mortality in a world of perfect transporter clones is just bizarre. Any non-stupid application of the tech would have people running dozens of clones and backups and so on in an afternoon.
I suspect there are laws against just that sort of thing. Plus: we only see the episodes that feature "successful" transporter cloning. Perhaps, just offscreen, transpo-clones are an hourly occurrence, but they virtually always result in the clone not being just messed up, but horrifically so. Imagine the transporter accident from TMP was a regular result when someone tries to make a clone.
 
And since Federation clearly allows a significant level of political dissent (all those "weird colonies" that Picard & Co visited constantly), we could safely assume that Federation did not like to brainwash its citizens unless they are truly unrepetant criminal types.
There is a significant difference between "not thinking like you" and "actively wishing for the destruction of your existing society"
 
Those would be two data points between which dissent crosses the line into "the regime deals with this by surveillance, harassment, fines, incarceration, torture, reprogramming and/or death". Where this line lies, and which sanctions are chosen for which infractions, is the regime's decision.
"The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few" can have nasty consequences.
 
Last edited:
Ferengi d-kora class star shipI .

I wonder how many shops or warehouses they had on the ship itself.
It somehow looks to me like it was built in the style of an 80s skyscraper by the designers of the NG series View attachment 765362
Possibly like one of John Portman's atrium hotels. This is the San Francisco Hyatt Regency.
 

Attachments

  • 960px-Hyatt_Regency_SF.jpg
    960px-Hyatt_Regency_SF.jpg
    300.7 KB · Views: 1
  • Hyatt_Regency_San_Francisco_(110103874).jpg
    Hyatt_Regency_San_Francisco_(110103874).jpg
    161.4 KB · Views: 2
Overall, the hotel looks like some milder form of brutalism from the 70s.
Maybe the idea with the Ferengi is that humanity will move in that direction of profit
 
And in Star Trek, there are a LOT of "gods." Their interactions with each other remain unexplored outside of beta canon.
Most of which got defeated by humans when they started to misbehave. It's more an argumet against being religious in Star Trek universe; the god you worship may very well turns out to be sufficiently advanced alien bratty manchind, who got his ass already kicked by Enterprise crew.
 
Most of which got defeated by humans when they started to misbehave. It's more an argumet against being religious in Star Trek universe; the god you worship may very well turns out to be sufficiently advanced alien bratty manchind, who got his ass already kicked by Enterprise crew.
A lot of 'em *didn't,* though. The Metrons, Organians, Thasians, V-Ger, Whale Probe, Prophets, Trelane's folks, Nagilum, Douwd, Caretaker, cosmic Koala... these folks showed up, did their thing and were *not* defeated by Our Heroes. Often enough they simply used the crew for whatever purpose then lost interest or were finished with that purpose and wandered off.

Actually *beating* the gods, like Apollo or arguably sometimes Q, was a rarity.

Given that people today like to worship ephemeral and minimally talented celebrities, worshiping or just following even the lamest of the Star Trekkian gods seems entirely likely.
 

Similar threads

Please donate to support the forum.

Back
Top Bottom