Brickmuppet
ACCESS: Secret
sferrin said:covert_shores said:The project does seem to be real and probably simply about missile shields. Maybe they are hoping to cancel it in exchange for halting missile shield development and deployment?
They can't possibly be worried about missile shields. If GBI achieved 100% success rate it wouldn't make a dent. For example, load up an Oscar with 24 nuclear armed land-attack P-700s, park it off Virgina, and what could stop those missiles from launching a decapitating strike. Certainly not GBI. On the other hand these Russian "torpedoes" would be the perfect terror weapon. If say, Russia decided to go into Poland, a NATO country, and the US decided to attack Russian units with conventional forces, Russia could send these torpedoes on their way to NY, DC, Seattle, Sand Diego, etc. They'd be loud enough we'd certainly detect them. But they'd be recallable. Unlike ICBMs Russia could say, "back off and we'll stop them". Imagine the pressure on a US administration to sit on it's hands and do nothing. 10 hours of bedlam.
Eww.
Well, that would certainly fit into their supposed plans to break NATO politically.
The "we'll stop them." part is the most crucial aspect of that scenario and potentially the weakest link in the chain.
Another possibility might be that the thing has multiple speed settings with varying degrees of quiet and the great range is intended in part to quietly, during peacetime, sneak up rivers which are inherently challenging environments for ASW. This thing is big for a torpedo, but comparatively small for a sub. St. Louis would be unlikely to be reachable but take out and irradiate New Orleans, Baton Rouge and Mobile and you shut a huge chunk of the trade from the central US down. As noted above, the junction of the Anacostia and Potomac is an obvious target, though that would be a challenging shot to say the least and would have to get past Norfolk (which is a target itself).
I don't think it necessarily even needs to be "salted" with cobalt or anything to count as dirty. The dirty (full yield) version of Tsar Bomba has been estimated at 52% fission fraction which, for a 100 MT is quite dirty indeed.