- Joined
- 16 December 2010
- Messages
- 3,263
- Reaction score
- 2,953
Alistair MacLean, The Guns of Navarone, 1957
United Kingdom
HMS Sybaris
'Heavy Cruiser', class not specified
8 inch main battery
No other details provided
HMS Sirdar
S Class Destroyer
Details as per the real ships.
Described as "...His Majesty's latest S-class destroyer..."
Note: As noted above the author explicitly identifies the ship as an S Class Destroyer. The name clashes with that of an S Class Submarine.
HMS Wryneck (D21)
V & W Class Destroyer
Real ship, details as in service (1918 - 1941)
Slamat
Transport Ship (Converted merchant ship?)
No other details provided
Note: Appears in a characters backstory.
Unnamed
MTB
No other details provided
Germany
Unnamed
Armed Caique
Armament: 1 x 40mm Gun, 2 x Machine guns, either MG-34 or MG-42s, author simply refers to them as 'Spandaus' a term which could fit either gun.
Crew: 6(+)
Battery Naverone
2 x 280mm (11 inch) Krupp K5 guns in modified mountings.
Note: The author gives three different sizes for the two guns that make up the battery in the novel. In the opening briefing scene the characters are told that the best intelligence information indicates the guns are either 8 inch or 9 inch weapons. When the characters reach the battery one of them identifies the weapons as being 12 inch guns. In the 1961 film, the size of the weapons is unspecified. However the depicted carriages are clearly based on the carriages used for the Krupp K5 11 inch guns. After discussion with Hood, I've decided to go with what the film depicts for this German Army installation. Both book and film indicate the guns are radar controlled.
Plot summary: The year is 1943, the British attempt to occupy the Dodecanese islands following the Italian surrender has failed in the face of a determined German counterattack. The garrison of the last island still under British control needs to be evacuated, but the clear routes to the island are blocked by the powerful German battery on the island of Navarone. Well protected, it has proven impossible to neutralize the guns by conventional attack so SOE is ordered to provide a team of experts to infiltrate the island of Navarone and destroy the guns.
Note: This is Alistair MacLean's second novel and in 1961 became the first to be filmed, the success of this film led directly to the classic war film (and Novel) 'Where Eagles Dare' (1967) and several other adaptions well into the 1970s. I have covered several of the authors other novels in this thread, they are: 'HMS Ulysses' (1955), 'South by Java Head' (1958), 'Night Without End' (1959), 'San Andreas' (1984) and 'Santorini' (1986)
The first of the two covers attached is from the 50th printing of the novel in October 1985. The artist is not identified. Like some other covers used for the novels it depicts three guns, rather than two, but does show all of them mounted on a turntable so they can be aimed. The second attached cover is from the 1993 printing of the novel and appears to be the last artwork cover created for the novel prior to the advent of CGI/Photomanipulated covers. As with the 1985 cover the artist who depicts the battery firing on a King George V Class Battleship (Thanks to Hood for the class identification.) is unidentified.
United Kingdom
HMS Sybaris
'Heavy Cruiser', class not specified
8 inch main battery
No other details provided
HMS Sirdar
S Class Destroyer
Details as per the real ships.
Described as "...His Majesty's latest S-class destroyer..."
Note: As noted above the author explicitly identifies the ship as an S Class Destroyer. The name clashes with that of an S Class Submarine.
HMS Wryneck (D21)
V & W Class Destroyer
Real ship, details as in service (1918 - 1941)
Slamat
Transport Ship (Converted merchant ship?)
No other details provided
Note: Appears in a characters backstory.
Unnamed
MTB
No other details provided
Germany
Unnamed
Armed Caique
Armament: 1 x 40mm Gun, 2 x Machine guns, either MG-34 or MG-42s, author simply refers to them as 'Spandaus' a term which could fit either gun.
Crew: 6(+)
Battery Naverone
2 x 280mm (11 inch) Krupp K5 guns in modified mountings.
Note: The author gives three different sizes for the two guns that make up the battery in the novel. In the opening briefing scene the characters are told that the best intelligence information indicates the guns are either 8 inch or 9 inch weapons. When the characters reach the battery one of them identifies the weapons as being 12 inch guns. In the 1961 film, the size of the weapons is unspecified. However the depicted carriages are clearly based on the carriages used for the Krupp K5 11 inch guns. After discussion with Hood, I've decided to go with what the film depicts for this German Army installation. Both book and film indicate the guns are radar controlled.
Plot summary: The year is 1943, the British attempt to occupy the Dodecanese islands following the Italian surrender has failed in the face of a determined German counterattack. The garrison of the last island still under British control needs to be evacuated, but the clear routes to the island are blocked by the powerful German battery on the island of Navarone. Well protected, it has proven impossible to neutralize the guns by conventional attack so SOE is ordered to provide a team of experts to infiltrate the island of Navarone and destroy the guns.
Note: This is Alistair MacLean's second novel and in 1961 became the first to be filmed, the success of this film led directly to the classic war film (and Novel) 'Where Eagles Dare' (1967) and several other adaptions well into the 1970s. I have covered several of the authors other novels in this thread, they are: 'HMS Ulysses' (1955), 'South by Java Head' (1958), 'Night Without End' (1959), 'San Andreas' (1984) and 'Santorini' (1986)
The first of the two covers attached is from the 50th printing of the novel in October 1985. The artist is not identified. Like some other covers used for the novels it depicts three guns, rather than two, but does show all of them mounted on a turntable so they can be aimed. The second attached cover is from the 1993 printing of the novel and appears to be the last artwork cover created for the novel prior to the advent of CGI/Photomanipulated covers. As with the 1985 cover the artist who depicts the battery firing on a King George V Class Battleship (Thanks to Hood for the class identification.) is unidentified.
Attachments
Last edited: