- Joined
- 11 March 2012
- Messages
- 3,122
- Reaction score
- 2,962
OTL M. Gregor’s reluctance to install a low wing was normal for the 1930s when few engineers understood how to streamline exit airflow from the wing roots of low-winged airplanes. That airflow gets more complicated when a circular fuselage is involved. The problem lays deep in the acute included angles where wings meet fuselage.…..
I have a bigger issue with "Gregor wanted to shift the wing to the bottom of the fuselage...". Michael Gregor left Seversky Aircraft primarily because he was unhappy with the low placement of Alexander Kartveli's wing. He wanted that wing placed in the aerodynamically ideal mid-position on 'his' SEV-3 fuselage. (For some reason, Gregor had no issue with the low placement of 'bottom' wings on his Brunner-Winkle Bird designs, GR series, or Model 10 FDB-1 biplanes. ….
Grumman initially solved the problem by installing mid-wings - on the F4 Wildcat/Martlet) for the shallowest possible interference angles (say 90 degrees). Grumman continued that aerodynamic philosophy with their later: Hellcat, Avenger, Bearcat and Tiger Cat which had wings mounted high enough on circular fuselages to minimize interference angles.
Severesky did similar on most of their P-47, F-84 and F-105.
North American did a similar wing root configuration when it installed wings part way up flat fuselage sides on its widely-successful P-51 Mustang. Most modern light singles copy the P-51’s wing-root to square fuselage shape.
Meanwhile, Supermarine did the opposite with a perfect elliptical wing mated to a perfect rounded fuselage. The tiny included angles required massive, 3D curved wing root fairings to smooth exit airflow.
Fast forward to the Reno Air Races 2023 Sport Class dominated by slab-sided Glassairs and beautifully curved Lancairs. But to win, Lancair race number 55 needed a massive, bulged, squared-off “beluga belly” to fill in the area of turbulent airflow. From the second-place perspective … er … below and behind … Lancair number 55 looks more like a boxy Glassair.