Reply to thread

The Great Pacific War, by Hector Bywater, published in 1925 is one of the the classic alternate history/alternate war fictions. Bywater dabbled in warship design, for example the fictional Indomptable commerce raiding hybrid cruiser-seaplane carrier that he proposed in 1925 in an article for U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings in cooperation with fellow author-analyst Maurice Prendergrast.

Most of the warships in The Great Pacific War are real-world ships, with only the Japanese cruiser-submarines approaching fictional levels of whiffery (2,500 mines on a submarine is insanity) which adds to authenticity. The book would probably be much less famous had it not seemed to presage the Pacific campaign of WW2 - the book dealing with a Japanese attack on the Philippines and other US territories in 1931 (6 years in the future), the outbreak of which is not an attack on Pearl Harbor but instead sabotage of the Panama Canal by exploding a freighter packed with TNT inside it to cause a landslide. Aircraft though do play a powerful role, particularly torpedo bombers (dive-bombing seems to make little impact) but paradoxically aircraft carriers play less of a role, all new construction in the book is of small carriers carrying 20 or so aircraft and the Japanese even convert Kaga and Akagi back to capital ships!

The bulk of US building is Treaty cruisers - tinclads, some probably built incredibly too quickly, even quicker than WW2 mass production of such ships. Diesels feature heavily to increase range for transpacific voyages, even in destroyers.

On to the ships!


Japan


Kaga: real aircraft carrier, reconverted to a battleship during 1931-32 with a displacement of 40,000 tons, armed with 5x2 16in turrets and a max speed of 23kt; sunk by US battleships in 1932


Akagi: real aircraft carrier, reconverted to a battlecruiser during 1931-32 with a displacement of 44,000 tons, armed with 4x2 16in turrets and a max speed of max speed of 30kt


4x unnamed: battleships with a displacement of nearly 50,000 tons and armed with ?x 18in guns; laid down in 1931


Asama: real Asama-class armoured cruiser, rearmed with forward 8in turret replaced by 2x1 12in howitzers for shore bombardment; damaged by coastal batteries on Guam in 1931


Tokiwa: real Asama-class armoured cruiser, rearmed with forward 8in turret replaced by 2x1 12in howitzers for shore bombardment; damaged by coastal batteries on Guam in 1931


Nisshin: real Nisshin-class armoured cruiser; sunk by coastal batteries on Guam in 1931


Myoko: real Myoko-class heavy cruiser (which had only just been laid down when the book was published)


Chitose: heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons, armed with ?x 8in guns and with a max speed of 34kt, built during the 1920s; name clashes with a protected cruiser stricken in 1928 and a seaplane carrier completed in 1936


Kasagi: heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons, armed with ?x 8in guns and with a max speed of 34kt, built during the 1920s; sunk while attacking a convoy


Yoshino: heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons, armed with ?x 8in guns and with a max speed of 34kt, built during the 1920s


Tatsuta: real Tenryu-class light cruiser fictionally sunk by a US torpedo bomber in 1931


Hamakaze: real Isokaze-class destroyer fictionally sunk by USS S-18 in 1931


Hosho: real aircraft carrier


Matsushmia & 3x unnamed: aircraft carriers with a displacement of just under 6,000tons, carries an airgroup of 15x aircraft and has a max speed of 28kt; Matsushmia is sunk off Guam by US bombers in 1931


Hakata: a ex-civilian fast steamer converted into an auxiliary aircraft carrier, disguised as a British Blue Line freighter, armed with 4x1 6in guns concealed in deckhouses and carries an airgroup of 20x seaplanes; sorties with submarine I-54 to bomb the US West Coast


Fushimi: real gunboat on Yangtze River, fictionally sunk by USS Palos (PG-16) in 1932


Hodzu [Hozu]: real gunboat on Yangtze River, fictionally sinks the USS Palos (PG-16) in 1932


Ro.51: real Type L-class submarine, fictionally captures the US-flagged freighter Orient in 1931


I-53: real Kaidai Type 3A-class submarine, fictionally operated from temporary base near Cape Horn in 1931 and sunk by US naval forces


I-54: submarine with a displacement of 2,000 tons and is armed with 2x1 5.5in deck guns and ?x torpedo tubes; operated off San Diego but sunk by destroyers USS Rathburne and USS Shirk; pennant clashes with a Kaidai Type 3A-class submarine completed in 1927


I-58: submarine operated from temporary base near Cape Horn in 1931 and sunk by US naval forces; pennant clashes with a Kaidai Type 3A-class submarine completed in 1927


I-59: submarine, sunk off Truk in 1931; pennant clashes with a Kaidai Type 3B-class submarine completed in 1930


Nagasaki, Hakodate, Kobe, Osaka, Nagoya & 1x unnamed (+2 under construction): cruiser submarines designed by German engineers, first laid down spring 1925 at Kure; have a displacement of 7,080 tons (surf) and dimensions of 405 x 45ft; armed with 1x2 8in turret (500rpg) and 3x1 4in deck guns, 8x hull & 2x deck torpedo tubes (1x submarine completed without the turret and instead has 2,500x mines); powered by 29,000hp diesels for a max speed of 23kt (surf) and electric motors for 11kt sub, have a range of 24,000nm; Nagasaki lost, Hakodate rammed and sunk by battleship Yamashiro and Nagoya sunk by US warships


Tsurugizaki: real oiler, fictionally sorties with auxiliary aircraft carrier Hakata


Akashi Maru: a civilian steamship deliberately blown up to block the Panama Canal in 1931


Aso Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and badly damaged by submarine; name clashes with a motor ship built in 1932 impressed as a gunboat in 1938


Hanno Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by submarine


Nagasaki Maru: a civilian steamer of Nippon Yusen Kaisha line completed in 1923converted into an auxiliary cruiser during 1931 armed with 4x1 6in guns and 2x2 torpedo tubes; has a displacement of 5,272 tons gross and a max speed of 20kt; operated in the Atlantic sinking the auxiliary cruiser USS George Washington and USS Leviathan and capturing USS Mount Vernon


Nikko Maru: a civilian steamship captured by submarine USS S-4 in the Philippines in 1931


Osaka Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by submarine


Sado Maru: a liner of N.Y.K. Line, used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by bombing; name clashes with a steamer built in 1898 and used during Russo-Japanese War and not broken up until 1934


Sendai Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by submarine; name clashes with a motor fishing vessel built in 1933


Shanghai Maru: a civilian steamer of Nippon Yusen Kaisha line completed in 1923converted into an auxiliary cruiser during 1931 armed with 4x1 6in guns and 2x2 torpedo tubes; has a displacement of 5,272 tons gross and a max speed of 20kt; operated in the Atlantic sinking the auxiliary cruiser USS George Washington and USS Leviathan and capturing USS Mount Vernon


Tsubari Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by bombing


Wakasa Maru: a civilian steamer used as transport for invasion of the Philippines in 1931 and sunk by bombing


Aircraft


Asahi: bomber with a 1.5 ton (1,360kg) bombload


Torpedo Bomber: carries 2x 23in torpedoes


Large Seaplane: carries a 0.5 ton (450kg) bombload; carried aboard the auxiliary carrier Hakata



USA


Asiatic Fleet – based at Manila, Philippines


Missoula (CA-13): real Tennessee-class armoured cruiser fictionally sunk in battle with the Japanese Fleet in 1931


Frederick (CA-8): real Pennsylvania-class armoured cruiser fictionally sunk in battle with the Japanese Fleet in 1931


Cleveland (CL-19): real Denver-class light cruiser fictionally scuttled in Manila Bay in 1931


Denver (CL-14): real Denver-class light cruiser fictionally sunk in battle with the Japanese Fleet in 1931


Galveston (CL-16): real Denver-class light cruiser fictionally sunk in battle with the Japanese Fleet in 1931


Curtiss: small aircraft carrier, carries an airgroup of 14x aircraft (8x fighter, 6x torpedo bombers), has a max speed of 22kt, built in the 1920s; sunk in battle with Japanese Fleet by gunfire in 1931


10x destroyers, including named vessels:


Crosby (DD-164): real Wickes-class destroyer fictionally sunk in battle with Japanese Fleet in 1931


Hulbert (D-342): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally sunk in battle with Japanese Fleet in 1931


Osborne (DD-295): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally sunk by a Japanese light cruiser trying to escape from Manila in 1931


Dent (DD-116): real Wickes-class destroyer fictionally escapes from Manila but sunk just off Guam by a Japanese submarine in 1931


Lamberton (DD-119): real Wickes-class destroyer fictionally escapes from Manila to Guam in 1931


Rizal (DM-14, ex-DD-174): real Wickes-class destroyer fitted as minelayer fictionally escapes from Manila to Guam in 1931


3x light minelayers


12x submarines, including named vessels:


S-4 (SS-109): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally not lost in 1927 and captures the Japanese merchant ship Nikko Maru off the Philippines in 1931


S-10 (SS-115): real S-class(1st Group) submarine fictionally sunk by a mine in 1931


S-11 (SS-116): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally rammed and sunk by a Japanese while attacking troop transports in 1931


S-15 (SS-120): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally sunk while attacking Japanese troop transports in 1931


S-18 (SS-123): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally sinks Japanese Isokaze-class destroyer Hamakaze in 1931


S-19 (SS-124): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally scuttled in Manila Bay in 1931


S-23 (SS-128): real S-class (1st Group) submarine fictionally escapes from Manila to Guam, sunk by mine while escaping to USA in 1931


S-50: real S-class (4th Group) submarine fictionally escapes from Manila to Guam, escaped to USA in 1931


Pacific Fleet ships/new construction


4x unnamed: battlecruisers with a displacement of 52,000 tons, armed with 4x2 18in turrets and a max speed of 35kt, laid down in 1931


Alaska: aircraft carrier; escort for a fleet of decoy battleships in 1932


Curtiss: aircraft carrier, a replacement for the sunken USS Curtiss, completed in 1932


Harvard: aircraft carrier, completed in 1932 ; takes part in invasion of Pelew Islands in 1932


Monatuk: aircraft carrier, completed in 1932


Wright: aircraft carrier, completed in 1920s


Charlotte (CA-12): real Tennessee-class armoured cruiser fictionally recommissioned in 1931


Huntingdon (CA-5): real Pennsylvania-class armoured cruiser fictionally recommissioned in 1931


Huron (CA-9): real Pennsylvania-class armoured cruiser fictionally nearly sunk during Japanese sabotage of the Panama Canal in 1931


Atlanta: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32


Cleveland: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1932; sunk by the Japanese battlecruiser Akagi in 1932; name clashes with Denver-class light cruiser (CL-21) completed in 1903 and decommissioned in 1929


Columbia: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931; sunk by Japanese armoured cruisers off Samoa in 1931


Columbus: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32


Denver: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931; name clashes with Denver-class light cruiser (CL-16) completed in 1904 and decommissioned in 1933


Hartford: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32


Kansas City: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32


Los Angeles: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32


Minneapolis: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, built during the 1920s; sunk in a battle with Japanese cruisers in 1931; name clashes with New Orleans-class heavy cruiser (CA-36) completed in 1934


Olympia: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32; name clashes with protected cruiser (C-6) stricken in 1922 and earmarked as a museum ship (IX-40) in 1931


Portland: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, built during the 1920s; name clashes with Portland-class heavy cruiser (CA-35) completed in 1933


Wilmington: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with 3x3 8in turrets, completed in 1931-32; name clashes with Wilmington-class gunboat (PG-8) completed in 1897 and decommissioned in 1945


Albany-class

Albany: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with ?x 8in guns, carries 2x seaplanes, completed in 1931


Troy: a heavy cruiser with a displacement of 10,000 tons and armed with ?x 8in guns, carries 2x seaplanes, completed in 1931; sunk by the Japanese battlecruiser Akagi in 1932


10x unnamed: heavy cruisers with a displacement of 10,000 tons, armed with 3x3 8in turrets, powered by 60,000hp diesels for a max speed of 28kt, laid down in 1931


5 unnamed: heavy cruisers with a displacement of 12,000 tons, armed with 3x3 8in turrets and powered by diesels, laid down in 1932


Aaron Ward (DD-132): real Wickes-class destroyer fictionally recommissioned in 1931 and damaged by Japanese minefield off San Diego


Ballard (DD-267): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally damaged by Japanese minefield off San Diego in 1931


Farragut (DD-300): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally still in commission in 1931


Hopewell (DD-181): real Wickes-class destroyer fictionally recommissioned in 1931


Laub (DD-263): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally damaged by Japanese minefield off San Diego in 1931


Melvin (DD-335): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally still in commission in 1931


Reid (DD-292): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally still in commission in 1931


Thompson (DD-305): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally sunk by Japanese minefield off San Diego in 1931


Yarborough (DD-314): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally sunk by Japanese minefield off San Diego in 1931


Zeilin (DD-313): real Clemson-class destroyer fictionally still in commission in 1931


?x unnamed: destroyers powered by diesels and steam turbine propulsion, laid down in 1931


?x unnamed: destroyers with a displacement of 1,500 tons, laid down in 1931-32


V-7: ocean-going submarine with a displacement of 1,700 tons (surf), completed in 1931-32; name clashes with USS Dolphin (ex-V-7) (SS-169) completed in 1932


V-11: ocean-going submarine with a displacement of 1,700 tons (surf), completed in 1931-32


20x unnamed: ocean-going submarines, laid down in 1931-32


Arlington: naval transport, rams the USS Marquette and sinks in 1931


Bath (AK-4): real naval transport fictionally still in commission in 1931, armed with 2x MGs, scuttled following damage from Japanese submarine off Guam in 1931


Beaufort: naval transport, used to send supplies to the Philippines but diverted to Guam in 1931


Marquette: naval transport, rammed by the USS Arlington and sunk in 1931


Nikko Maru: Japanese civilian steamship captured by submarine USS S-4 near the Philippines and impressed as a fleet auxiliary


Newport News (AK-3): real naval transport fictionally still in commission in 1931, used to send supplies to the Philippines but diverted to Guam in 1931


George Washington: real civilian liner of United States Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931; operated in the Atlantic, sunk by Japanese auxiliary cruiser Nagasaki Maru and Shanghai Maru


Leviathan (ex-SS Vaterland): real civilian liner of United States Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931; operated in the Atlantic, sunk by Japanese auxiliary cruiser Nagasaki Maru and Shanghai Maru


Mount Vernon (ex- SS Kronprinzessin Cecilie): real civilian liner of United States Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns; operated in the Atlantic, captured by Japanese auxiliary cruiser Nagasaki Maru and Shanghai Maru


President Cleveland: real civilian liner of American President Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931; operated in the Atlantic


President Jefferson: real civilian liner of American President Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931


President Madison: real civilian liner of American President Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931; operated in the Atlantic


President Pierce: real civilian liner of American President Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931; operated in the Atlantic


President Taft: real civilian liner of American President Lines fictionally converted into an auxiliary cruiser with ?x 6in guns in 1931



Aircraft


Chicago: large rigid airship


Back
Top Bottom