Fake Russian projects

[hesham]

Hi,


I can't ID those projects,who can help ?.

 

[Stargazer]

Source?

 

[borovik]

Fake 100%

Of a text written in broken Russian (about how I write in English)) that this is the period 1928-1941 Sikorsky Aircraft's ...
Probably strongly influenced by Ernst Heinkel AG ;D

 

[Nick Sumner]

I'd say fakes. The second drawing has a tail lifted from an He 177 while the third, fourth and fifth have Do17/215 tails. The third and fourth have wings/engines pinched from a pre WW2 French medium bomber project. Alt history?

 

[Jemiba]

... and N° 3 and 4 wings were taken directly from the Breguet Br.482.
Would be good to know the source, as either it's an alt.history site,
or just a "fake slinger" !

 

[hesham]

OK my dears,

here is the source,and I agree ,it is fake;


http://alternathistory.org.ua/vopros-k-kollegam?page=2

 

[Stargazer]

Yep, completely fake. And just take a look further down at these "Russian" "Seversky Kartvelishvili SK-47 Drosd" (Thrush) of 1936 if you still need confirmation... or the "Sikorsky S-44" of 1938 just below it!

 

[Jemiba]

Well, we had that site before and the problem is, that what is shown there, isn't completely
fake. There are lots of real aircraft and projects and the problem is to decide: What is true
and what is false ? But that's a reason for a forum like this one, too.

 

[redstar72]

Well, we had that site before and the problem is, that what is shown there, isn't completely
fake. There are lots of real aircraft and projects and the problem is to decide: What is true
and what is false ?

I wrote once:

About aviation topics on Alternathistory: those from http://alternathistory.org.ua/forum/1434 subforum ("Less known and unrealized aircraft designs") are historical, while those from http://alternathistory.org.ua/forum/1896 ("Alternative aviation") are what-ifs. At least it's what must have been - there are some topics placed in "wrong" sections.

http://www.secretprojects.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,17666.msg168558.html#msg168558

Everybody can also ask me, or Borovik, or flateric...

Regarding the "SK-47 Drozd" - it is simply the "first" (cancelled) Republic XP-47 repainted into Russian Imperial markings...