So, I was sent a review copy of American Experimental Fighters of WWII by Tony Buttler by Crecy. Cheers, Tony. My honest review is below. Comments and corrections welcome, I'll repost elsewhere later.
American Experimental Fighters of WWII: The Pursuit of Excellence is the latest book by veteran (and forum favourite) author Tony Buttler on Crecy's Hikoki imprint.
The book is beautifully presented, printed on thick, high quality paper and very well illustrated with photographs. Its pretty thick, with 320 pages. There are 24 chapters, each covering one aircraft type, two appendices, and an index.
Aircraft covered are Curtiss XP-46, Lockheed XP-49, Grumman XP-50 Skyrocket. North American XP-51 Lightweight Mustangs, Vultee XP-54 'Swoose Goose'. Curtiss XP-55 Ascender, Northrop XP-56 Black Bullet Lockheed XP-58 Chain Lightning, Curtiss XP-60 and XP-40Q, Curtiss XP-62, McDonnell XP-67 Bat. Republic XP-47H, XP-47J and XP-72, Hughes XF-11/XP-73/XA-37, Fisher XP-75 Eagle, Bell XP-77, Northrop XP-79, Convair XP-81, Bell XP-83, Bell XFL-1 Airabonita, Boeing XF8B-1, Curtiss XF14C-1, Curtiss XF15C-1, Grumman XF5F-1 Skyrocket and Ryan XF2R-1 Dark Shark.
There's an unfortunate typo on the index, "Northrop XP-56 Black j100" instead of "Northrop XP-56 Black Bullet", but this is not reflected in the main text which has been edited with great care. Not Tony's fault, it obviously happened in layout.
While the photos are exceedingly well reproduced, some of the 3 views while reproduced fine could have benefitted from some retouching to clean them up in my opinion. This is an area where Chris Gibson, Dan Sharp and I appear to have widely differing opinions, so its more of a personal preference than a criticism. (Tony, my offer to edit the 3 view drawings for your books for free was genuine, hit me up for the next book).
In writing this book, Tony has drawn on a reserve of previously unseen primary material and it shows, both in the text and in the picture selection. He has also been able to rely on the assistance of a stellar array of best-in-class researchers and authors, including Alan Griffith, the late Gerry Balzer, and other well-known names that will be familiar to Secret Projects forum members and serious aviation book aficionados. This network of contacts has helped Tony in his quest to find something fresh on every aircraft covered in this book.
The chapters vary in length from 7 pages (Curtiss XP-46) to 27 pages (Curtiss XP-62). Each chapter generally consists of an outline of the development program for the aircraft, some early concepts or alternative layouts considered if new material was available, the flight testing of each prototype and results thereof, and a technical description of the aircraft.
I will confess I'm more of a jet guy than a propellerhead, and my WW2 obsessive phase was mostly over by age 13, so some of the designs here were unfamiliar to me beyond the name. As Antonio mentioned its not a book about the development of US WWII fighters as a whole, but more of a compilation of 24 monographs on US WW2 fighter prototypes.Rather than reading it end to end as a single unified book, I found it much more enjoyable to dip in and read a chapter or two at a time, which is why this review took a little longer to arrive than usual.
When reading Tony's more project-focused books, as a reader I felt there was always the possibility that each unbuilt project described might have achieved its goals if built, however unliely in most cases. In this book, the failings and limitations of the various prototypes are documented, leaving the subjects of the book caught in a no-mans-land between the untested promise of unbuilt projects, and the real-world success of production aircraft. Sometimes, it turns out, you have to build a plane to find out it wasn't a good idea.
American Experimental Fighters of WWII is an excellent book, and is a valuable reference book in my ever increasing collection. If you like WW2 fighters, if you like prototypes, you will enjoy this. Even if you have some existing books covering some of the aircraft included, its going to have new information and photos you haven't seen before.